Tuesday, 17 November 2026

Scathing Review of a Kind Professor and The Fountainhead by Ayn Rand

 



My daughter is an English major in college (like I was) and she's a literature fanatic as well as an author in her own right. She pulled this book out and I was enthused because I read this as an idealistic young religious zealot when I was just her age (19).

So I re-read this (kind of a cheater poorly abridged audio version but I was able to listen to it while driving on a trip - and we listened some together until she was appalled to discover so many passages that had been cut out). It's true the audio version cut out major sections that one could consider to be instrumental to the plot and character development. The abridger must not have liked Catherine Halsey's character because her sections are mostly omitted. 

When my eighteen/nineteen year old self read this (I can't quite remember) - I deeply admired the concept of a pure passionate pursuit of some kind. It appealed to my earnest nature. Having been raised as an ardent conservative, I applauded the virtues of stoicism, self-madeism, independence and free-market competition. I'm basically a libertarian still so in that regard I guess I haven't changed much. However, my younger self's main takeaway was that the passionate pursuit should be channeled into religious zealotry. I was very shaped by Paul's epistles and his very serious, heavy, undertones of apocalypticism. That sounds like a wine description:

St. Paul's Vintage

intense and astringent 
undertones of bossiness and overbearing opinions about inane details 
heavy flavoring and difficult to pair with modern times
aftertaste of guilt 

So, all this to say, when I read the Fountainhed I applied a Roark like lens to others and basically approved or disapproved of them based on a template of whether they appeared to be single-minded fanatics or not. This all came to a head at my first semester Communications class at Bridal College my naughty nickname for Bible College when we were asked to give a speech in which we were instructed to interview a faculty member and then present what we learned about them (and it was filmed). This is so mortifying. I interviewed a kindly mild mannered English professor about his life. Apparently I found him wanting in the appropriate amount of zealotry. He probably didn't have probing intense eyes (like Gary Cooper who plays a kind of old version of Roark in the movie) and he probably came across like the caring family man, professor, writer, and generally nice person he was. (what a crime obviously) I remember my speech to be somewhat scathing - something to the effect that he (proffie) seemed to be devoid of passion. (I hope it was less unkind then I remember and that the poor man never encountered the filmed version of my speech). I even remember my Communications professor (friend of her poor scathed colleague) protesting rather vehemently about my review of his "lack of passion." (She had verve - I probably approved of her.)

Anyway. This time around. Well my idealism ran me to the ground so I'm now a jaded person who aspires to a minimal amount of kindness and decency which I think seems to be unattainable to lots of people including myself oftentimes. I don't aspire to grand achievements although I wish I did sometimes. I still enjoyed the characters but found the gravitas of the book more humorous than anything. We also watched the movie (which I'd never seen) and I giggled throughout the whole thing which I doubt is aligned with Ayn Rand's hoped for response. 


Not Nice Dr Aziz Gazipura


I guess recovering people pleasers read books like this as well as a recent audio Fuck Feelings which was actually really witty and funny and a recent one The Courage to be Disliked which I wrote about here. 

The author is very transparent and weaves in a lot of very personal stories. He is a coach and began his career following in the footsteps of Tony Robbins so the book feels like it has a lot of that high energy, what I think of as "American make it happen" fervor - she said with a touch of expat disdain. 

However, there are some good insights and you probably wouldn't understand how some people can become very other oriented at a very young age (sensitive types usually) and then it takes them literally decades to figure out how to care less about what other people think. It's quite excruciating. 

There is one thing that stood out. He talked about gearing up to be a little bit to be confrontational or standing up for himself in a way he normally wouldn't which felt great at the time, but afterwards he was swept with a wave of (buyers remorse - people pleaser remorse) where he literally second guessed himself and felt extreme angst in retrospect about his ballsy uncharacteristic boundary setting. That was extremely relatable. In fact, often when I consider being confrontational or setting boundaries in certain relationships, I usually choose not to because the ensuing discomfort feels so much worse to me than giving up my (Fill in the blank): time, money, remote control, food choice, place to put my feet where the dog wants to lay,...

So it's really a matter of deciding where to put your energy and what battles are worth fighting for. I can get very easily triggered with certain relationships into thinking that I have slighted someone in some way by omission or commission and start obsessing about it when like as not, the other person wasn't even aware of an offense. Sensitive people can become very adept at reading into things. This gives them a sort of ESP power which can be useful but they can also be guilty of conjuring up meanings to things that were never felt or intended. 


 

Radical Acceptance by Tara Brach

 


I discovered Tara Brach because I was looking for guided meditations on You Tube. I started reading a bit about her work which integrates Buddhist Fusion (I may have invented that term not sure) meditation and spiritual practices with clinical psychology. 

As we become so global and ideas are so easily accessible there is a lot of room for fusion and I think less tolerance for rigidly defined categories. 

I've never been good at meditating or prayer. I have monkey mind which I realize is not unusual but it makes sitting still and focusing on the present very difficult. I can meditate when I'm weeding, hiking, driving, showering though. Now, thanks to Libby the free library app with constant access to audio books even those spaces are usually filled with input. I do yoga though and am able to be pretty mindful during those short practices. I have learned through my readings over the years that meditation isn't this mystical inaccessible voodoo power achievable only by the few - it's more like just being mindful in whatever you're doing and trying to stay present. Years ago I read Eckhart Tolle's The Power of Now and have since encountered other ideas demystifying spirituality. I approach my accounting work like meditation with attention and presence. I try to wash dishes, fold laundry, and do other tasks with slow calm mindfulness and it's very serene. (especially if I can listen to my book while I'm doing it!)

I felt a lot of compassion for Tara as she shared her story. I felt she had a lot of pressure put upon her or upon herself as a young person. Buddhist spiritual practices helped her navigate to a more manageable way of living and it seems like in her work and in this book there is a desire to help people find greater freedom and joy and to relieve themselves of the pressure (self imposed or societal) that can lead to unhappiness and depression. 

I enjoy self help books because often it's like having a conversation with someone and someone who has put some thought into something or tapped into a system or idea that has helped them. I always get inspired. My relational sphere is somewhat limited by working full time in a very small company, and the remainder spent mostly with family. I don't meet a lot of new people or socialize much outside of those realms so reading books is a way of connecting with a broader community. 









A Clearing in the Distance; Frederick Law Olmstead by Witold Rybczynski

 


There's an unholy amount of consonants jammed together in this author's last name. 
This was a book club read. 

My favorite thing about this book, which was a skim read for me due to a high level of technical info about landscaping, is the discussion about his life and times and many other topics which spawned at my book club. My fellow book club members are freaking geniuses. I adore them. One of them is like an encyclopedia and I have a terrible penchant for collecting smart people. I barely deigned to open my mouth for fear of sounding ignorant amidst such greatness. I muttered a few virtually undistinguishable utterances. 

I'm terribly delayed in this reflection and there are 3 others I wish to write and I think there were some standout things about this - bear with me. It's very goal oriented I realize, but I can't help it - firstborn daughter of a firstborn daughter and firstborn granddaughter energy. 

- I'm jealous of the way he had the privilege due to birth, affluency, and the times to meander his way into a profession - exploring various pursuits with the unhurried luxury only a noble gentrified indebted bachelor male of the mid 19th century could be. 

- He married his widowed sister-in-law kind of lateish in life which I think is interesting. She had children and then they had more together. 

- famous for designing and undertaking the construction of Central Park. The vision including that of recreating American landscapes for the common laborer to experience at a snow's throw away.