My daughter is an English major in college (like I was) and she's a literature fanatic as well as an author in her own right. She pulled this book out and I was enthused because I read this as an idealistic young religious zealot when I was just her age (19).
So I re-read this (kind of a cheater poorly abridged audio version but I was able to listen to it while driving on a trip - and we listened some together until she was appalled to discover so many passages that had been cut out). It's true the audio version cut out major sections that one could consider to be instrumental to the plot and character development. The abridger must not have liked Catherine Halsey's character because her sections are mostly omitted.
When my eighteen/nineteen year old self read this (I can't quite remember) - I deeply admired the concept of a pure passionate pursuit of some kind. It appealed to my earnest nature. Having been raised as an ardent conservative, I applauded the virtues of stoicism, self-madeism, independence and free-market competition. I'm basically a libertarian still so in that regard I guess I haven't changed much. However, my younger self's main takeaway was that the passionate pursuit should be channeled into religious zealotry. I was very shaped by Paul's epistles and his very serious, heavy, undertones of apocalypticism. That sounds like a wine description:
St. Paul's Vintage
intense and astringent
undertones of bossiness and overbearing opinions about inane details
heavy flavoring and difficult to pair with modern times
aftertaste of guilt
So, all this to say, when I read the Fountainhed I applied a Roark like lens to others and basically approved or disapproved of them based on a template of whether they appeared to be single-minded fanatics or not. This all came to a head at my first semester Communications class at Bridal College my naughty nickname for Bible College when we were asked to give a speech in which we were instructed to interview a faculty member and then present what we learned about them (and it was filmed). This is so mortifying. I interviewed a kindly mild mannered English professor about his life. Apparently I found him wanting in the appropriate amount of zealotry. He probably didn't have probing intense eyes (like Gary Cooper who plays a kind of old version of Roark in the movie) and he probably came across like the caring family man, professor, writer, and generally nice person he was. (what a crime obviously) I remember my speech to be somewhat scathing - something to the effect that he (proffie) seemed to be devoid of passion. (I hope it was less unkind then I remember and that the poor man never encountered the filmed version of my speech). I even remember my Communications professor (friend of her poor scathed colleague) protesting rather vehemently about my review of his "lack of passion." (She had verve - I probably approved of her.)
Anyway. This time around. Well my idealism ran me to the ground so I'm now a jaded person who aspires to a minimal amount of kindness and decency which I think seems to be unattainable to lots of people including myself oftentimes. I don't aspire to grand achievements although I wish I did sometimes. I still enjoyed the characters but found the gravitas of the book more humorous than anything. We also watched the movie (which I'd never seen) and I giggled throughout the whole thing which I doubt is aligned with Ayn Rand's hoped for response.



